Frank Herbert and his son are very different writers. Where Frank Herbert spends a lot of time playing the psychologist for the main characters and goes into depths, resulting in me feeling disconnected at times (especially in Messiah), his son does not go into those depths.
The chapters in the books of the father are usually two or three times longer than a chapter in the books of the Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson, so less time is spent on characters in general per chapter but they usually also have more characters. I wouldn't call the characters superficial because of that, but they write the books primarily as an adventure and not as a proclamation, which is what I feel Frank Herbert is doing.
I also think they do it on purpose, because they don't want to take anything away from the original 6 books and give their own spin on things. As mentioned these books written by Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson are of varying quality, but so are the books of the father in my opinion. I find it difficult to determine upfront which books are worth the read and which are not, so I just went all-in.
Besides that, the books are also written in sets of trilogies, so once started I also feel the need to finish that particular trilogy.
The chapters in the books of the father are usually two or three times longer than a chapter in the books of the Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson, so less time is spent on characters in general per chapter but they usually also have more characters. I wouldn't call the characters superficial because of that, but they write the books primarily as an adventure and not as a proclamation, which is what I feel Frank Herbert is doing.
I also think they do it on purpose, because they don't want to take anything away from the original 6 books and give their own spin on things. As mentioned these books written by Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson are of varying quality, but so are the books of the father in my opinion. I find it difficult to determine upfront which books are worth the read and which are not, so I just went all-in.
Besides that, the books are also written in sets of trilogies, so once started I also feel the need to finish that particular trilogy.
- Joined
- Aug 30, 2006
- Messages
- 11,223