I was deeply enthralled in Gothic 3 back at release, but I ended up with a corrupt save game and lost about 50 hours of playtime.
Since then, I've never been able to get back into it properly.
But the game has a special place in my heart - and it was one of the few games that could pull me away from WoW at the time.
Incidentally, I seem to recall joining the Watch right around the time this game was released - and it was one of the first games I talked about around here.
Doesn't hurt that the soundtrack is one of the best of all time.
Also, it remains the only PB game that has dual wielding - which is a big deal to me
I've played it here and there since then, and also with the various mods and community fixes - but I just think it's fundamentally flawed and I doubt it will ever be truly "fixed" to the extent it would need to be to feel like a wholesome experience.
Still, I'm happy to try out this mod at some point - when it's more mature.
As for stuttering, yeah, I think that's still an issue when streaming content as you move around.
It's even more noticeable today, as seamless open worlds are commonplace. Back then, it was more of a feat - and I had an easier time forgiving it, because the game was just beautiful.