Not sure how you get to the idea that we think it's all fun and games with no effort. Everything we've been discussing in this thread is an acknowledgement of how that's very much NOT the case. But, I don't think that has much to do with the points we were discussing.
But you have to bear in mind that we don't know you from Adam, and we weren't involved in the decision, so we might want to discuss it. There's a huge amount of positivity around the decision, so I don't think a few skeptical voices are a problem, and IMO are appropriate. It won't be an issue for you, because as you'll probably have discovered before, most people will go along happily enough without rocking the boat. If we bang on too much, they'll start telling us off.
And there are a few reasons to be skeptical, IMO. For example, the matter of what your TOS says, and yet you being a regular participant on the Codex, including that delightful "The Watch is Dead" thread. Not that I care what goes on at the Codex - they're free to play by their own rules, as far as I'm concerned. But it does raise the question of what other policies might be stated but ignored. And when you say that not every word on your site is still relevant, to us that means we can't know what's accurate and what's not.
So, for me, a few things that I find a bit questionable.