Elden Ring - AAA game publishers have hard lessons to learn
- Thread starter Silver
- Start date
Maybe I should, if you have any good ones to start with I'm happy to read them. I'm mostly going by his Dark Souls comments too, so I'm not as up on what he has said about Elden Ring.
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2011
- Messages
- 2,163
JFarrell71
SasqWatch
Miyazaki and FROM have a pretty good idea of what and who constitutes the worlds they build. Lore descriptions are not randomly thrown out there. There's a consistency that wouldn't exist if that was the case. I know this from playing the games myself, and from reading various interviews with Miyazaki over the years. I wouldn't be able to find most of them now, but here's a snippet from an interview I do know how to find, talking about Big Hat Logan:
"Miyazaki: I suppose it wasn't. As to why I made him naked, I wanted to show that the character had found enlightenment but unfortunately the models in Dark Souls weren't built with a wide range of emotional expressions, so as I was thinking about how to overcome this problem, for some reason, I came up with the idea of making him naked…
It's Logan's goal to gain the power of the ancient dragons, so in order to do this, I had an image of him casting off his human clothes. It's similar to using the Dragon Head or Torso Stone, you have to remove your equipment. Of course there are gameplay reasons for this too, but there was also this image of the player leaving something of their humanity behind. Similarly, Logan removing his clothes is his attempt to bring himself closer to Seath in some way. Although I couldn't take his hat off because no one would recognise him, but personally I like to think that unlike the followers of the path of the Dragon, Logan sought to gain the dragons power while retaining his pride as a human."
The interview is largely about character/monster designs, but there's still a lot of good stuff in there that shows the thought process behind the games. https://darksouls.wiki.fextralife.com/Dark+Souls+1+-+Design+Works+Interview
Most of it just seems to be about theme and imagery though. I would never deny that Miyazaki is the master of creating memorable themes.
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2011
- Messages
- 2,163
Lore is obviously not their strong point. Let's not even try to pretend otherwise.
I agree with fadedc about the open world. I like it a lot. It's all about personal taste of course, but I vastly prefer it over the design of the DS games.
I agree with fadedc about the open world. I like it a lot. It's all about personal taste of course, but I vastly prefer it over the design of the DS games.
JFarrell71
SasqWatch
It's absolutely one of their strong points. I don't have to pretend. I'll take what they do over the fiftieth copy/paste Tolkein/D&D based world any day.
I think the rest of us know by now that you'll take anything that has to do with this game over anything from any other game.
JFarrell71
SasqWatch
I think the rest of us know by now that you'll take anything that has to do with this game over anything from any other game.
I wrote a rather long post on this thread about how I won't, but that's okay.
Actually the lore is quite deep. It’s presenting the lore and story telling that’s not their strong point.
I don’t think anyone will have to worry too much about a bunch of Elden ring clones. Open world games are just too expensive. Look at the success of Skyrim and we are not inundated with Skyrim clones.
I’m really enjoying the game now after treating the open world as I believe FromSoft intended and that is as a travel mechanism and farming area for crafting and runes. I was disappointed at first at the lack of rewards for exploring but after playing I can see why they did it. With the horse you can pretty much traverse the open world with little to no fear of dying. If the overworld was full of great weapons and armor everyone would just ride to it and grab it right away.
I’m approaching 200 hours now (which includes several restarts) and plan to post my thoughts in a separate thread when I get a chance to do it properly.
I don’t think anyone will have to worry too much about a bunch of Elden ring clones. Open world games are just too expensive. Look at the success of Skyrim and we are not inundated with Skyrim clones.
I’m really enjoying the game now after treating the open world as I believe FromSoft intended and that is as a travel mechanism and farming area for crafting and runes. I was disappointed at first at the lack of rewards for exploring but after playing I can see why they did it. With the horse you can pretty much traverse the open world with little to no fear of dying. If the overworld was full of great weapons and armor everyone would just ride to it and grab it right away.
I’m approaching 200 hours now (which includes several restarts) and plan to post my thoughts in a separate thread when I get a chance to do it properly.
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2021
- Messages
- 382
JFarrell71
SasqWatch
The Radahn fight is crazy. I wish I had more time to admire his design but I'm too busy trying (and so far failing) not to die.
That's one I definitely had to come back to much later.
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2011
- Messages
- 2,163
N
Nereida
Guest
A lof ot the encounters are really epic and well designed, and it's a shame the bosses doesn't stand still more often so you can admire that design!
To put one negative to the boss fights, I just found a little offputting that some of the bosses are rehashed/recoloured skins of previous bosses you found. There are some bosses that have the same design and attack pattern and you get to fight 5 or 6 times each. And I don't mean bosses that are found later in the game as "trash mobs", I mean actual bosses with boss bar and a different name.
To put one negative to the boss fights, I just found a little offputting that some of the bosses are rehashed/recoloured skins of previous bosses you found. There are some bosses that have the same design and attack pattern and you get to fight 5 or 6 times each. And I don't mean bosses that are found later in the game as "trash mobs", I mean actual bosses with boss bar and a different name.
JFarrell71
SasqWatch
Yeah, a byproduct of the open world design and sheer number of boss fights. A lot of the mini dungeons have copy/paste bosses.
All of the major bosses are very cool, though. The Rennala fight was outright beautiful, visually and auditorily.
I don't see how being open-world has anything to do with reusing the same bosses.
JFarrell71
SasqWatch
Really?
Making the game open world meant peppering it with a lot more dungeons and bosses than usual for their games. Having limited time and resources while making the game several times larger than normal meant recycling some bosses with minimal variation.
You're talking about size and length. The level design has nothing to do with it. You said it as if being open-world automatically means stuff like that happens. It doesn't.
JFarrell71
SasqWatch
Because everyone just loves big empty open worlds, right? Good god, you love to argue. You and Lackblogger should be locked in a room.
It's ok. I'm sure you just meant that the game is big.
It's true, a lot of the mini-dungeon bosses are kind of throw away bosses and not super interesting.
I don't usually mind though. By the time I've gotten to the end of the dungeon and I'm carrying a giant pile of runes I'm usually very happy for a nice easy fight to finish things off.
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2011
- Messages
- 2,163
Way back when, Mechwarrior 2 was think ultimate game.
Maybe you're right. Mech2, these days, is a bit slow and clunky. But, fuck, if anyone can bring me back to mech days its gotta be from, yeah?
I dunno. we'll see. I'm definitely paying attention.