I find that what I enjoy about games has evolved over time, so what I once enjoyed is now just annoyingly repetitive. (E.g. blobbers.) I'm sure that evolutionary aspect must be true for other gamers, especially after they've been playing for a long time. Anyway, I'm not that critical a person so I can sometimes enjoy a game that gets widely panned. (Dragon Age II, for example.) The only way to know for sure is to actually play it. But that's a great thing about the game industry; eventually everything drops in price until it reaches the point where I'm willing to give it a try.