Might and Magic series really drew me in and also Wasteland had great atmosphere. For a newer game Skyrim really made me feel like I was there. For a MMO the original Everquest just had amazing atmosphere when it was new.
Example by contrast: Diablo 3 wasn't very atmospheric at all, IMHO.The music in the original Diablo had that "suck me in and not let go" feeling to it also (one of the only games I actually keep the music on for).
I'd like to point out that almost every atmospheric game mentioned can be considered an RPG classic. Does that mean atmosphere is the only thing that matters for everyone ?
LotrO was wonderfully atmospheric back in SoA and Moria.
Then of course: Bloodlines. Good lord, that might be one of the finest examples of atmosphere in any genre, let alone just within RPGs. While the combat, interface, and even basic character movement have not aged kindly (to put it gently), the atmosphere is still enthralling, and I have a feeling that it will be timeless in that regard.
Absolutely. Exploring the Trollshaws was magical.
I agree the atmosphere is great in Bloodlines, but I think the exploration and story/writing represent the primary draw - for me.
What server are you on, Neph? Nobody's ever on mine (Arkenstone)…